Hootsuite vs. Sendible, or Why Paying To Use Facebook Is Amazing

***EDIT: This post is no longer up to date, and I no longer use Sendible because they have since grown to suck while Hootsuite has grown to rule. I’m keeping this post live for archival purposes only. Please read my UPDATED review of Hootsuite here.***

‘Social media’ won’t exist in three years because by then all media will somehow have become ‘socialized’. It will just be ‘media’ again.

That said, I’ve built my comedy career via social media. Since I perform live at universities, most of my audience has a vibrant digital life. This means, whether I like it or not, my shows don’t end when the stage lights turn off — they just move to Youtube, or Twitter, or Facebook, or even Yelp.

At this point, I pay to use services that are free to the public, because I have no choice.

Since 1) my fans gather in multiple locations online, and 2) between my assorted accounts I’ve garnered a total friend/fan/subscriber/follower count well into five figures, and 3) there’s only one of me, I need a comprehensive solution for effectively communicating with all of these people.

Not broadcasting, mind you — communicating. That means responding and participating and engaging with the people who take the time to enjoy my funny stuff.

So, if you relate to expecting digital intimacy from tens of thousands of college students, you might already know about Hootsuite or Sendible. They’re both services allowing users to harness social networks with an advantageous level of control.

Hootsuite

I was using Hootsuite, which lets folks cross-post to multiple accounts and track keywords that others post. You can hit send once and post a Twitter, Facebook, and Foursquare status scheduled for 5pm PST next Wednesday. You might then track users mentioning the term ‘[Your Name]’ in their posted statuses, in real time. That’s useful when I know in advance I’ll be touring through areas with poor internet connectivity. I might schedule, “Have you seen the poster for this Friday’s show? [link]” to post Monday, “Here’s the Facebook event for my free show this Friday @ 9pm! [link]” to post Wednesday, and, “See you at the show tonight!” to post Friday morning.

Hootsuite originally let me add an unlimited number of social accounts, and I eventually became proficient enough at it (lots of retweets, ‘likes’, and actual butts in seats at shows) that friends started asking me to help with their social campaigns.

Within a few months, I was coordinating about thirty accounts through Hootsuite, and it was beautiful. They were an eclectic bunch — a few musicians, a dance company, some comedy websites, a few community organizations, and some individuals I’ll just call ‘over forty years old’.

Click to enlarge. This is the Hootsuite interface. Enter your statuses in the top box, select networks in the little boxes, and monitor different live status feeds in the columns.

Perched atop my social tower, I observed the flow of data and optimized everyone’s experience. I ensured that the bands retweeted and shared each other’s promo, allowing their separate fan bases to congeal into one digital scene. The comedy websites now never posted overlapping content at the same times, ensuring maximum clickability. The community organizations supported the dance company’s fundraisers, giving relevance to two hard-to-promote groups. And, all of these accounts could now take advantage of a timely hashtag at once.

It was a lot of work, and everyone involved benefited almost constantly. Especially me, experience-wise: consulting everyone’s accounts taught me how to best manage my own.

Then, fuckin’ Hootsuite started charging.

Yeah, it was a great service for a bunch of reasons, but was it worth paying six bucks or even fifteen hundred bucks per month? I had already invested others and my time and promotional capital in this service, and it would be terrible suddenly halting forward momentum on thirty social accounts because of a fee.

I was already paying $30 monthly for my awesome mailing list through Constant Contact (average for a list of three thousand or so email addresses) and I really didn’t want to add to my growing digital expenses. I figured, if I had to upgrade to a pay social media service, I might as well compare apples to apples with other Enterprise-class services.

Sendible

I don’t know which god I pleased, but I soon found Sendible. It might be best described as ‘macro-social networking’.

Sendible does everything Hootsuite does, significantly better. Plus a bunch of stuff Hootsuite definitely can’t do.

Multiple accounts? How about multiple services per account. Sendible can schedule future Facebook statuses, Facebook posts, Facebook notes, Facebook photo albums, Facebook group messages, Facebook personal messages — even posts to any of your friends’ personal walls at once. It’s uniquely powerful, and must be wielded with a deep, mature respect towards one’s social community, lest there be a massive opportunity for abuse and Myspace-ification. That said, Sendible grants users the ability to disseminate information with remarkable scale and granularity, and when used responsibly, can be very effective.

And that’s just Facebook.

Click to enlarge. Sendible’s interface is as simple as most email services.

The interface is just like Gmail, except I can send messages well beyond other email addresses. Sendible schedules and posts tweets, Foursquare shouts and venue tips, LinkedIn status and personal messages, as well as WordPress and Tumblr blogs, Flickr albums, and even SMS/text messages.

It’s one inbox for pretty much everything.

Beyond merely scheduling statuses, Sendible can auto-follow relevant Twitter accounts by keyword. So, I’m a comedian; Sendible automatically identifies and follows users tweeting the keywords ‘comedy’, ‘comedian’, ‘stand-up’, or ‘funny’ for me.

Share This

16 Comments on “Hootsuite vs. Sendible, or Why Paying To Use Facebook Is Amazing

  1. Pingback: Why I Love Hootsuite, Hate Sendible, and Why "Social Media" Doesn't Matter Anymore - Max Goldberg | Max Goldberg

  2. Pingback: Sendible vs Hootsuite « Sendible Blog

  3. Pingback: Sendible Blog» Blog Archive » Sendible vs HootSuite

  4. Max,
    Great article on Sendible, I wanting to possible use it for 5 twitter accounts, 4 facebook pages, 3 web sites, 3 blog sites and Google+.

    Are you still using HootSuite Pro or only using Sendible.

    Can you give everyone an update on your experience over the past 9 months on with Sendible. Are they still meeting all your social media needs after 9 months.

    Do you have any experience with their White Label platform?

    Thanks in advance for you assistance.

  5. I am a huge fan of Sendible as well. Especially after reading your excellent piece, I feel like I am just scratching the surface for what it can do.

    I really like the nicely formatted newsletters Constant Contact helps me put together. Do you do HTML newsletters when you use Sendible? Or have you reverted to basic-looking emails.

    Thanks for a great article!

    • I don’t use HTML newsletters, no, but I wouldn’t call my regular-looking emails ‘reverting’. If the content rocks, it helps not having the distractions of templates sometimes. This is actually how I used to do it with Constant Contact as well.

      Have you tried the new streams columns in the inbox yet? They’ve officially out-hooted Hootsuite.

      m

  6. Hey mate

    Great review of Sendible. I am in the early stages of checking it out and it looks like it ticks plenty of boxes.

    I didn’t think about replacing my email marketing provider (AWeber) with Sendible.

    Cheers
    Matt

    • Let me know how it goes. What’s your project?

      m

  7. Pingback: Have you ever heard of Sendible? I help several clients with social media and am looking for a workable dashboard to juggle all the accounts. So far, Sendible is good, but always trolling for better. - Quora

  8. Pingback: ROUND-UP: My favorite posts of 2010. « maxgoldbergonline.com

  9. Thanks for this. Just been forced to pay for Hootsuite cos dodn’t know about Sendible. Gonna give Sendible a try as I have a lot of tittwer accounts to manage.

    Grateful for the insight.

    • Gladly.

      I just started using Hootsuite’s Pro plan to test it out, and I don’t plan to keep it. I guess it’s everything I liked about Hootsuite’s original, free plan …except now you have to pay. If you’re deep enough into social media campaigning to justify paying to post status updates, the much-better deal is clearly Sendible.

      • UPDATE: I’m hanging on to Hootsuite’s Pro plan, but only as a back up in case Sendible crashes or something.